Some scuffs (haven’t tried to remove) but the metallic surface of the leather is still intact except for some tiny scratches near the edge/bottom. Inside foot beds and soles are quite clean. These are super comfy shoes with good arch support. Velcro’s are in great shape. I can hold these up to another size 12 or size 11 in another brand if you request. If anything these run small. I think we wore when my daughter was about an 11 1/2 shoe size.